NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss Non-Sticky Lip Gloss

NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss Non-Sticky Lip Gloss

Editor's Take

NYX gets the glossy, cushiony finish right, but Mineral Oil and Polybutene keep it firmly in throwback drugstore territory rather than modern formulation.

DARE score
4.0/10
Performance
7.8
Clean Standards
1.9
Innovative Ingredients
4.5
Formula Sustainability
1.7

Highlights

  • Titanium Dioxide: mineral-based colorant support
  • Polybutene: high-viscosity film for maximum light refraction and shine
  • Beeswax: natural structuring agent for cushion and barrier comfort

Concerns

  • Incidental oral exposure: incidental ingestion is expected with lip products
  • Synthetic Fragrance: undisclosed synthetic fragrance may contain potential allergens
  • Petroleum-derived base: utilizes mineral oil and paraffin waxes
  • Lip ingestion (L2): EFSA's 2021 opinion concluded titanium dioxide (E171) could no longer be considered safe as a food additive due to unresolved genotoxicity concerns; the EU banned its use in food effective August 2022. Cosmetic use remains permitted.
  • Lip ingestion (L2): EFSA's CONTAM Panel (2012, updated 2023) flagged mineral hydrocarbons (MOSH/MOAH) for measurable accumulation in human tissue after chronic oral exposure. Mineral-hydrocarbon ingredients in lip products are an incidental ingestion route worth noting.

DARE vs Yuka: whole-formula scoring compared →

Ingredient-by-ingredient breakdown
Pro
Recommendations
Pro

Unlock the full ingredient breakdown and recommendations with Pro.

  • Full analysis on every product
  • Recommendations for products that meet your standards
  • Unlimited analyses
  • Unlimited Compare Mode
  • Unlimited history
  • Priority new features
  • Cancel anytime
  • Ingredient-by-ingredient breakdown
Upgrade to Pro