tarte products scored by DARE

DARE has scored 2 tarte products. Average overall score: 7.1/10. Category: makeup. Highest overall score: tarte maneater™ mascara, 8.0/10.

BRAND VERDICT

Is tarte clean? DARE's verdict

At a glance

Products scored2
Avg overall7.1/10
Avg Clean Standards7.7/10
Clean range7.3–8.0

Highest overall: tarte maneater™ mascara (8.0).

Lowest overall: tarte shape tape™ blurring concealer stick (6.2).

Scores from analyses dated 2026-10-19 to 2026-10-23. Clean Standards is DARE's rating of ingredients against its human-health criteria; it is not a medical or safety determination. How DARE scores

Is tarte clean?

It depends on the product. Across the 2 tarte products DARE has scored, the average Clean Standards score (DARE's human-health score) is 7.7/10, from 7.3 (tarte shape tape™ blurring concealer stick) to 8.0 (tarte maneater™ mascara). The average overall score, which also weighs Performance, Innovative Ingredients and Formula Sustainability, is 7.1/10.

What are the best tarte products according to DARE?

  1. tarte maneater™ mascara 8.0
  2. tarte shape tape™ blurring concealer stick 6.2

Does tarte use fragrance?

Neither of the 2 tarte products DARE has scored lists fragrance (parfum) as an ingredient. DARE weighs scent ingredients in the context of the whole formula under Clean Standards rather than scoring them in isolation.

BRAND VERDICT

Are tarte formulas sustainable? DARE's verdict

At a glance

Products scored2
Avg overall7.1/10
Avg Formula Sustainability5.1/10
Formula Sustainability range1.3–8.8

Highest Formula Sustainability: tarte maneater™ mascara (8.8).

Lowest Formula Sustainability: tarte shape tape™ blurring concealer stick (1.3).

Scores from analyses dated 2026-10-19 to 2026-10-23. Formula Sustainability is DARE's rating of a formula's ingredients against its sustainability criteria; it is not a certification. How DARE scores

Are tarte formulas sustainable?

It depends on the product. Across 2 scored tarte products, average Formula Sustainability is 5.1/10 (range 1.3 to 8.8). Formula Sustainability is DARE's rating of a formula's ingredients against its sustainability criteria; it is not a certification.

Which tarte products score highest on Formula Sustainability?

  1. tarte maneater™ mascara 8.8
  2. tarte shape tape™ blurring concealer stick 1.3

DARE vs Yuka: whole-formula scoring compared →

ProductOverallPerformanceInnovative IngredientsClean StandardsFormula Sustainability
tarte maneater™ mascara8.0 / 108.26.88.08.8
tarte shape tape™ blurring concealer stick6.2 / 108.27.87.31.3